by Emmitt Barry, Worthy News Washington D.C. Bureau Chief
(Worthy News) – A federal appeals court is weighing whether Kansas City can use its public accommodation ordinance to require Christian counselors to counsel gay married couples despite the counselors’ biblical convictions on marriage and sexuality.
The case, now before the 8th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, involves licensed counselors Wyatt Bury and Pamela Eisenreich, who say Kansas City and Jackson County ordinances violate their constitutional rights by forcing them into counseling relationships and conversations that conflict with their Christian faith.
According to Just the News, Kansas City attorney Tara Kelly acknowledged during oral arguments that counselors who offer marriage counseling to heterosexual couples could not refuse to counsel same-sex couples based on sexual orientation or gender identity. The city argued that its law regulates discriminatory conduct, not speech, and said counselors remain free to express their Christian beliefs during counseling sessions.
But that position drew sharp questions from the appellate panel. Judges pressed whether the ordinance effectively forces Christian counselors to accept clients and engage in counseling relationships that violate their conscience.
The dispute comes after the U.S. Supreme Court recently ruled in favor of Colorado counselor Kaley Chiles, blocking enforcement of a state counseling restriction and requiring similar laws to face strict scrutiny, the highest level of constitutional review. That ruling has now placed local counseling bans and related ordinances under renewed scrutiny nationwide.
Alliance Defending Freedom, which represents Bury and Eisenreich, argued that Kansas City’s law chills Christian speech because counselors risk penalties if they clearly state in advance that they provide counseling consistent with biblical beliefs about marriage and gender. ADF attorney Bryan Neihart told the court that the city’s position remains inconsistent, especially because the counselors could be punished for saying certain counseling services would not affirm same-sex marriage.
Kansas City has indicated it may repeal portions of its counseling ban, but it has continued defending the broader public accommodation ordinance. That law remains central to the case because it could require Christian counselors to serve gay married couples in the same category of counseling they provide to heterosexual couples.
For Christian professionals, the case raises a sobering question: can the government force believers to provide services in a way that contradicts Scripture, even when the service itself involves speech, counsel, and moral guidance?
Supporters of religious liberty argue that compassion and conscience are not enemies. Christians can treat every person with dignity while still refusing to affirm what they believe violates God’s design for marriage.
The 8th Circuit has not yet issued its ruling.
Copyright 1999-2026 Worthy News. This article was originally published on Worthy News and was reproduced with permission.
More Worthy News
Israel observed Shabbat on Saturday amid fresh diplomatic tensions with the European Union and several Western nations over plans to expand settlements in the West Bank, known biblically as Judea and Samaria, and a separate dispute over a deadly Israeli strike on an aid convoy in Gaza.
NATO’s chief has sought to reassure Bulgaria of the military alliance’s support amid reports that Iran has weighed attacking American military targets in Europe if U.S. President Donald J. Trump orders renewed or expanded strikes against the Islamic Republic.
New evidence has emerged suggesting that this week’s massacre of Christians in Nigeria’s Plateau State was part of coordinated attacks on several predominantly Christian communities, as questions mounted over why security forces allegedly failed to intervene despite advance warnings.
Kevin Rideout, an American Christian missionary who spent more than nine months in captivity after being abducted by suspected Islamic militants in Niger, and his wife thanked believers for their prayers after they were reunited.
Egyptian archaeologists say new discoveries in northeastern Egypt may help identify a long-lost ancient city that stood along one of the most important military roads of the ancient world — a route many scholars have connected to the biblical account of the Exodus.
Israel’s High Court of Justice has unanimously overturned the government’s decision to close the influential Army Radio after 75 years, ruling that ministers acted at least partly on “improper and invalid” political considerations because they objected to the station’s broadcasts.
Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu told Jared Kushner that Israel remains firmly opposed to the creation of a Palestinian state, making the position “very clear” during a meeting this week with the Trump adviser, according to a senior Israeli official cited by JNS.