by Emmitt Barry, Worthy News Washington D.C. Bureau Chief
MINNEAPOLIS (Worthy News) – A federal judge on Monday heard arguments from the state of Minnesota seeking an emergency halt to the Trump administration’s deployment of thousands of federal immigration agents to the Twin Cities, a sweeping operation that has intensified tensions between state and federal authorities following a fatal shooting involving a Border Patrol agent.
The case centers on “Operation Metro Surge,” a federal initiative that has brought thousands of Immigration and Customs Enforcement and Customs and Border Protection officers into Minnesota over the past two months. Minnesota officials argue the surge violates state sovereignty and the 10th Amendment, while the Justice Department says the deployment is a lawful response to the state’s sanctuary-style policies.
U.S. District Judge Katherine Menendez, a Biden appointee, ended the hearing without issuing a ruling, citing the constitutional complexity and urgency of the dispute. She said the matter raises serious separation-of-powers concerns that may not be resolvable through a single district court injunction.
“One of the things I’m struggling with is that not all crises have a fix from a district court injunction,” Menendez said from the bench, noting that any decision would likely be appealed quickly to the Eighth Circuit.
State Alleges Coercion, 10th Amendment Violations
Attorneys for Minnesota and the city of Minneapolis argued that the Trump administration is using the massive federal presence to pressure the state into dismantling its sanctuary policies, a tactic they say violates the Constitution’s “anti-commandeering doctrine.”
Brian Carter, representing Minneapolis, told the court the state is asking for a return to the “status quo” that existed before Operation Metro Surge. He described the deployment as unprecedented, claiming as many as 3,000 to 4,000 masked and heavily armed federal agents have been sent into Minnesota.
“What we’re asking the court to do is to apply the 10th Amendment to prohibit the federal government from coercing the state into legislating or using its resources to affect a federal regulatory scheme,” Carter said.
Plaintiffs pointed to a Jan. 24 letter from Attorney General Pam Bondi to Minnesota Gov. Tim Walz, which demanded the state repeal sanctuary policies, share Medicaid and food stamp data, and provide voter rolls to the Justice Department. Minnesota argues the letter amounts to unconstitutional pressure on state lawmaking.
Justice Department Defends Federal Authority
Justice Department attorney Brantley Mayers rejected claims of coercion, saying the surge is a necessary enforcement response to Minnesota’s lack of cooperation with federal immigration authorities.
He told the court that if state policies changed, “it would change the reaction,” though he stopped short of committing to an end to the surge. Menendez pressed him on whether that position effectively tied policy concessions to the withdrawal of federal agents, raising potential 10th Amendment concerns.
Mayers also acknowledged uncertainty over the total number of agents deployed, estimating more than 2,000 ICE officers and possibly thousands more CBP personnel — an answer that appeared to frustrate the judge.
Fatal Shooting Raises Stakes
The hearing followed the Jan. 24 shooting of a U.S. citizen by a Border Patrol agent, an incident cited repeatedly by state attorneys as evidence that the current situation is “untenable.” Menendez ordered the federal government to preserve evidence related to the shooting.
She also questioned whether the surge’s outcomes match its stated goals, noting that many arrests appear to be “collateral” rather than targeted apprehensions of criminal offenders.
“Is there no limit to what the executive can do in the guise of enforcing immigration law?” Menendez asked.
Trump Signals Possible De-Escalation
The case has become a flashpoint in the broader clash over President Donald Trump’s aggressive immigration enforcement agenda. Over the weekend, Trump struck a more conciliatory tone, saying he had a productive call with Gov. Walz and that the two agreed to “work together.”
Trump confirmed he is sending border czar Tom Homan to Minnesota to assess the situation and explore next steps. The president also said a “major investigation” is underway into what he described as a massive welfare fraud scheme in the state.
Menendez suggested Trump’s public comments about cooperation could undermine the administration’s argument that an extraordinary show of federal force is necessary.
“What do I do with that?” she asked during the hearing.
With no immediate ruling, the court is expected to request additional information from the Justice Department, including an exact count of federal agents deployed. The outcome could shape the future balance between federal immigration enforcement and state sovereignty nationwide.
Copyright 1999-2026 Worthy News. This article was originally published on Worthy News and was reproduced with permission.
More Worthy News
The recovery of the final Israeli captive, Sergeant First Class Ran Gvili, during Operation Brave Heart in eastern Gaza City has removed the last major obstacle to reopening the Rafah Crossing, paving the way for the continued implementation of U.S. President Donald Trump’s 20-point plan for Gaza.
A federal judge on Monday heard arguments from the state of Minnesota seeking an emergency halt to the Trump administration’s deployment of thousands of federal immigration agents to the Twin Cities, a sweeping operation that has intensified tensions between state and federal authorities following a fatal shooting involving a Border Patrol agent.
A systematic organization behind riots in Minnesota exposed through leaked group chats is under investigation, says FBI Director Kash Patel.
Israel’s military confirmed Monday it recovered the remains of Ran Givli, a special forces officer killed in the Hamas-led October 7, 2023, attack on Israel, ending a more than two-year effort to bring him home.
The United States has formally completed its withdrawal from the World Health Organization, citing the organization’s handling of the COVID-19 pandemic, failure to implement meaningful reforms, and what U.S. officials described as undue political influence by member states.
The U.S. aircraft carrier USS Abraham Lincoln and its accompanying warships have entered the Middle East, according to U.S. officials, significantly expanding President Donald Trump’s military options as tensions with Iran continue to escalate.
Seven people died and a crew member survived with serious injuries when a private plane crashed while taking off at Bangor International Airport in the U.S. state of Maine, as steady snowfall from a massive winter storm swept across the region, aviation officials said Monday.