By Andrew Rice | The Center Square
(Worthy News) – The U.S. Supreme Court heard arguments Tuesday in two cases over whether biological males can participate in women’s and girls’ sports.
Little v. Hecox and B.P.J. v. West Virginia challenged state laws in Idaho and West Virginia, respectively, that prevent transgender women and girls from participating in female sports.
The justices weighed whether the sports bans violate the Constitution or Title IX, a federal law that prohibits sex discrimination.
Kathleen Hartnett, a lawyer representing transgender athlete Lindsay Hecox in Idaho’s case, said there is not a competitive advantage between cisgender and transgender people in sports when hormones are controlled.
“The testosterone is the advantage on this record,” Hartnett said. “This person had mitigated testosterone.”
Justices Neil Gorsuch and Brett Kavanaugh pointed to scientific uncertainty over whether blocking hormones eliminates a competitive advantage in sports. Both justices expressed uncertainty about creating a protected status for transgender individuals without more scientific consensus.
“Given that half the states are allowing it, half are not, why would we try to constitutionalize a rule for the whole country,” Kavanaugh asked.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett pointed to the state laws specifically prohibiting transgender girls and women from participating in sports on the basis of transgender status.
“Since trans boys can play on boys teams, how would we say this discriminates on the basis of transgender status,” Barrett asked.
In arguments over West Virginia’s case, lawyers clashed with the justices in multiple instances over legal tactics used to argue for or against transgender individuals participating in female sports.
“Biological sex matters in athletics in ways both obvious and undeniable,” said Michael Williams, West Virginia solicitor general. “The law is indifferent to gender identity because sports is indifferent to gender identity.”
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson pointed to inherent discrimination between cisgender women and transgender women. She appeared to signal the case must consider the differences in treatment under the law for both categories.
“The law operates differently for cisgender women and transgender women,” Jackson said.
Justice Sonia Sotomayor joined Jackson in apparent criticism of West Virginia’s legal arguments. She pointed to the lower court’s inability to find a violation of the equal protection clause, but did find a violation of Title IX.
“I’m not sure how it could do that, if the evidence is not sufficient to justify finding an equal protection violation its not a violation,” Sotomayor said.
Lawyers argued that West Virginia’s law treats Pepper-Jackson differently from other girls on sports teams throughout the state on the basis of sex. The lawyers said Title IX protections should extend to transgender individuals.
“If boys and girls as groups are being given equal sets of overall opportunity, every individual gets equal opportunity,” said Joshua Block, a lawyer for the American Civil Liberties Union who represented Pepper-Jackson.
Kavanaugh questioned whether the participation of transgender athletes would discriminate against cisgender girls and women who participate.
“Someone who tries out and makes it will bump someone else from the starting line up,” Kavanaugh said.
Justice Clarence Thomas also appeared to question the argument that a transgender individual could be included in Title IX protections when that status was likely not considered in the law’s passage.
“You’re challenging a category that does not exist in the statute but is dependent on the existence of the category in the statute,” Thomas said.
In a closing rebuttal, Williams asserted a strong link between biological sex and biological athletic performance. He also pointed back to questions of competing medical science.
“In areas of evolving science and medicine, legislatures have the primary responsibility for weighing competing evidence,” Williams said.
Copyright 1999-2026 Worthy News. This article was originally published on Worthy News and was reproduced with permission.
More Worthy News
Israel expanded its military campaign against Hezbollah on Monday, striking more than 70 targets across Lebanon as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed to increase pressure on the Iranian-backed terror group following a sharp rise in drone and rocket attacks on northern Israel.
A federal appeals court is weighing whether Kansas City can use its public accommodation ordinance to require Christian counselors to counsel gay married couples despite the counselors’ biblical convictions on marriage and sexuality.
Tens of thousands of evangelical Christians gathered in the Netherlands for one of Europe’s largest multi-day Christian events, with organizers and participants expressing hopes for spiritual revival in the nation and across Europe.
President Donald Trump pushed back Monday against sharp criticism from Republicans and former administration officials over a potential U.S.-Iran agreement, insisting that any final accord must prevent Tehran from obtaining a nuclear weapon or it will not be signed.
President Donald Trump said Monday that countries involved in negotiations over Iran should be required to join the Abraham Accords, signaling that the White House is seeking to turn a possible Iran agreement into a wider regional realignment that includes normalization with Israel.
Tensions remained high in Serbia’s capital Belgrade on Sunday after at least tens of thousands of people demanded elections and rallied against what they view as the increasingly authoritarian rule of President Aleksandar Vučić, with violence erupting after the protest and more than 20 people arrested.
Investigations were ongoing Sunday into the killing of three senior Kuki-Thadou Christian church leaders by unidentified gunmen in India’s northeastern Manipur State, Christian investigators told Worthy News.