by Emmitt Barry, Worthy News Correspondent
(Worthy News) – In a rare 4-4 decision, the U.S. Supreme Court on Thursday upheld a lower court ruling that blocks the establishment of the country’s first publicly funded religious charter school, leaving in place an Oklahoma Supreme Court decision that deemed the proposed school unconstitutional.
The case centered around St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School in Oklahoma City, which had been approved by the Oklahoma Statewide Virtual Charter School Board in 2023. The school would have received taxpayer funding while operating under the teachings and mission of the Catholic Church. It pledged to remain tuition-free and open to all students in accordance with state education laws.
Justice Amy Coney Barrett recused herself from the case, resulting in an evenly split court. Without a majority opinion, the Supreme Court issued a one-line, unsigned decision: “The judgment is affirmed by an equally divided Court.” No reasoning or vote breakdown was provided, as is customary in tie decisions.
The underlying ruling, issued by the Oklahoma Supreme Court on June 25, 2024, ordered the state board to cancel its contract with St. Isidore. The justices determined that the school functioned as a state actor and thus could not receive public funds without violating the Establishment Clause of the First Amendment and the Oklahoma Constitution’s ban on using public money to support religious institutions.
Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond, who brought the original challenge, praised the decision, warning that public sponsorship of religious education poses “a serious threat to the religious liberty of all four million Oklahomans.”
Advocates for school choice and religious liberty had hoped the nation’s highest court would recognize the school’s claim that it was being denied equal treatment based on its faith-based identity. Attorneys for St. Isidore argued that the state’s refusal to fund the school amounted to religious discrimination and a violation of the Free Exercise Clause.
During oral arguments last month, justices appeared sharply divided over whether religious charter schools should be considered public entities subject to constitutional restrictions–or private contractors with more freedom of religious expression.
The high-profile case, Oklahoma Statewide Charter School Board v. Drummond and St. Isidore of Seville Catholic Virtual School v. Drummond, leaves unresolved the larger question of whether states can or must include religious schools in publicly funded charter systems. Legal analysts expect the issue to resurface in future cases, given the growing interest in expanding school choice programs nationwide.
For now, the court’s deadlock means St. Isidore will remain closed, and the precedent set by Oklahoma’s highest court stands.
Copyright 1999-2026 Worthy News. This article was originally published on Worthy News and was reproduced with permission.
More Worthy News
Israel expanded its military campaign against Hezbollah on Monday, striking more than 70 targets across Lebanon as Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu vowed to increase pressure on the Iranian-backed terror group following a sharp rise in drone and rocket attacks on northern Israel.
A federal appeals court is weighing whether Kansas City can use its public accommodation ordinance to require Christian counselors to counsel gay married couples despite the counselors’ biblical convictions on marriage and sexuality.
Tens of thousands of evangelical Christians gathered in the Netherlands for one of Europe’s largest multi-day Christian events, with organizers and participants expressing hopes for spiritual revival in the nation and across Europe.
President Donald Trump pushed back Monday against sharp criticism from Republicans and former administration officials over a potential U.S.-Iran agreement, insisting that any final accord must prevent Tehran from obtaining a nuclear weapon or it will not be signed.
President Donald Trump said Monday that countries involved in negotiations over Iran should be required to join the Abraham Accords, signaling that the White House is seeking to turn a possible Iran agreement into a wider regional realignment that includes normalization with Israel.
Tensions remained high in Serbia’s capital Belgrade on Sunday after at least tens of thousands of people demanded elections and rallied against what they view as the increasingly authoritarian rule of President Aleksandar Vučić, with violence erupting after the protest and more than 20 people arrested.
Investigations were ongoing Sunday into the killing of three senior Kuki-Thadou Christian church leaders by unidentified gunmen in India’s northeastern Manipur State, Christian investigators told Worthy News.